How we make this list: we compare pricing pages, product documentation and public user reviews. Ratings come from G2, Capterra or Trustpilot, with the date we checked them.
Key takeaways
- Kirkus Indie is the most recognized name, with its most popular review option priced at $450 on its own site.
- BookLife, Foreword Clarion and BlueInk give trade-style credibility at lower or similar prices, with strong library and bookseller reach.
- Readers Favorite offers free reviews, which makes it the lowest-risk starting point for a debut author.
- Editorial reviews belong in the Editorial Reviews section of a book page, not posted as ordinary customer reviews.
- Never buy fake reader reviews. Amazon and other retailers remove incentivized reviews and can penalize the book.
Quick comparison
Is your product missing or out of date?
We review this list regularly. Vendors can request a listing, send updated pricing or ask about featured placement.
The best book review writing service
Starting price$450 per review
Free planNo
Kirkus has reviewed books since 1933, and that history is exactly what authors pay for. A Kirkus Indie review comes from professional reviewers including librarians, journalists and publishing professionals, and authors see the review before deciding whether to publish it. A negative review can stay private, which removes the biggest fear of paying for criticism.
The vendor's own page lists its most popular review option at $450, with expedited service costing more and cutting turnaround to roughly four to six weeks. Exceptional books can earn a Kirkus Star, a mark of merit that librarians and booksellers recognize, and standout reviews may appear in the magazine or newsletter. For an author pitching libraries, media or agents, no other paid review carries the same weight.
What we like- Most recognized name in paid editorial reviews
- Kirkus Star for exceptional books
- Reviews distributed to booksellers, libraries and partner sites
Watch out for- Highest price in this list
- Standard turnaround of seven to nine weeks
- No guarantee of a positive review
Starting priceSee website
Free planNo
BookLife is Publishers Weekly's platform for independent authors, and it offers the trade-name effect at a lower cost than Kirkus. Reviews commonly run around $399, with turnaround of four to six weeks, and each review includes an assessment of production elements like cover, design and editing alongside the critique itself. That production note is genuinely useful for self-published authors who lack a publisher's quality control.
Authors should understand one distinction: a paid BookLife review is not the same as an editorial review in the main Publishers Weekly magazine, though standout reviews may be considered for wider coverage. For authors who want a recognizable trade name without the Kirkus price, BookLife is the sensible middle ground.
What we like- Publishers Weekly association at a lower price than Kirkus
- Production assessment covers cover, design and editing
- Standout reviews may reach the main magazine
Watch out for- Reviews run shorter than some rivals
- Paid reviews appear separately from main Publishers Weekly editorial reviews
- Turnaround around four to six weeks
Starting priceSee website
Free planNo
Foreword Reviews has covered independent publishers for decades, and its Clarion review service extends that editorial eye to self-published books. Reviews run 400 to 600 words with a one-to-five star rating, and the magazine's readership among librarians and independent booksellers gives a good review a real distribution path beyond the author's own marketing.
Pricing is commonly reported in the $500 to $600 range, with discounts for some publishing association members, so confirm the current rate before ordering. The magazine also runs a PDF-first submission model for its editorial coverage, reflecting a shift toward digital review copies. For authors targeting libraries and indie stores, Foreword's audience is the right one.
What we like- Long-running indie review magazine with librarian and bookseller readership
- 400 to 600 word reviews with a star rating
- Strong curation reputation
Watch out for- Prices commonly reported at $500 to $600
- Turnaround of four to eight weeks
- No guarantee of a positive review
Starting priceSee website
Free planNo
BlueInk Review does one thing: review independent and self-published books. That focus means its reviewers judge indie work on its own terms rather than against traditionally published titles, and its reviews reach librarians and booksellers through Ingram and other channels. Strong books earn a Notable Titles designation that helps them stand out in the catalog.
Standard pricing is commonly reported around $445 with seven to nine weeks turnaround, and a fast-track option costs more. BlueInk lacks the household name of Kirkus, but for an indie author whose buyers are libraries and bookstores, its distribution and indie-only lens make it a strong alternative.
What we like- Focuses exclusively on self-published and indie titles
- Reviews shared with librarians and booksellers through Ingram
- Notable Titles highlight strong books
Watch out for- Prices commonly reported around $445
- Standard turnaround of seven to nine weeks
- Smaller brand recognition than Kirkus
Starting priceSee website
Free planNo
IndieReader has offered professional reviews to indie, hybrid and small-press authors since 2009, positioning itself at roughly half the price of larger competitors, commonly around $299 standard and $399 rush. Reviewers include working journalists, editors, librarians and published writers, and books scoring four or more stars earn an IR Approved badge plus eligibility for the Discovery Awards.
One caution: IndieReader also sells verified reader reviews posted to retail pages. Retailers including Amazon prohibit incentivized reviews, so treat any reader-review add-on with care and keep paid editorial reviews in the Editorial Reviews section where they belong. On the professional review alone, IndieReader is the value pick among established services.
What we like- Professional reviews for roughly half the price of larger rivals
- Star ratings with an IR Approved badge for four-plus stars
- Discovery Awards for standout titles
Watch out for- Smaller brand than Kirkus or Publishers Weekly
- Verified reader review add-on needs care around retailer rules
- New ownership may change offerings
Starting priceSee website
Free planNo
Reedsy Discovery is the budget editorial option with a clear promise: a flat fee commonly reported at $299, a review within about thirty days, and payment only for reviews actually delivered, with authors able to request up to five. That structure removes the two biggest risks of paid reviews, which are waiting months and paying for nothing.
Reedsy is best known as a marketplace for editors, designers and marketers, and Discovery extends that vetted-professional model to reviews. It will not carry the same library weight as Kirkus or Foreword, but for an author who wants an honest professional verdict at a contained price, it is the most straightforward deal here. Note that our homepage check returned only a thin page extract, so confirm current pricing on the site before ordering.
What we like- Flat fee commonly reported at $299
- Review guaranteed within about four weeks
- Pay only for reviews actually delivered
Watch out for- Homepage extract was thin during verification
- Reviewer pool is smaller than Kirkus
- Less library distribution than Foreword or BlueInk
Starting priceSee website
Free planNo
Self-Publishing Review is the budget end of professional reviews. Its Classic option is commonly reported at $149 for a review of at least 500 words with a newsletter mention, and higher tiers add bookshelf placement and an author interview shared on social media. Turnaround runs about thirty working days, shorter than the trade-name services.
The lower price comes with lower prestige: librarians and booksellers weigh a Self-Publishing Review verdict less than a Kirkus or Foreword one. Some packages mention posting to Amazon, which again needs care, since editorial reviews belong in the Editorial Reviews section rather than as customer reviews. For a debut author testing whether professional feedback is worth paying for at all, this is the cheapest honest entry point.
What we like- Classic review option commonly reported at $149
- Reviews of at least 500 words
- Newsletter, bookshelf and interview extras on higher tiers
Watch out for- Less trade prestige than Kirkus or BookLife
- Faster packages offer shorter reviews
- Amazon posting options need care around retailer rules
Starting priceFree
Free planYes
Readers Favorite is the outlier here because its core review service is free. Authors request a review, reviewers cover published and unpublished books across more than 150 genres, and five-star reviews earn a digital seal for the website and cover. The site also runs an annual award contest recognized by major publishers, and its review pages are indexed by search engines with star ratings.
Free means a queue: reviews are not guaranteed and timing varies, and only four- and five-star books appear publicly, with weaker books receiving private criticism instead. That selectivity keeps the site positive but limits its critical bite. For an author with no review budget, Readers Favorite is the obvious first request, and its award contest adds a second reason to enter.
What we like- Free reviews across 150 plus genres
- Five-star reviews earn a digital seal for the cover
- Annual award contest with major publisher recognition
Watch out for- Free reviews are not guaranteed and wait times vary
- Only four- and five-star books are listed publicly
- Negative reviews stay private as constructive criticism
How we chose
We compared vendor homepages and pricing pages against public comparisons and author guides, including Reedsy, Publishers Weekly and independent publishing sources. Every service here had its official homepage opened and confirmed, and each one offers genuine editorial reviews rather than fake reader reviews. Where the vendor does not publish a price on its homepage, we recorded "See website" instead of repeating third-party estimates.
What to weigh before you buy
Start with what the review is for. If you need credibility with librarians and booksellers, pay for Kirkus, Foreword or BlueInk and use the review in pitches and on the book's Editorial Reviews section. If you need honest feedback before launch, a cheaper service or a free Readers Favorite request gives you most of the value. If you need launch-week social proof, no paid editorial review substitutes for advance reader copies from real readers who chose the book freely.
Read the fine print on every service. Confirm the price, turnaround, review length, whether you can keep a negative review private, and where the review will be distributed. Never buy reviews that will be posted as ordinary customer reviews, and never join review swaps or paid reader pools, since retailers remove those reviews and can penalize the book. A paid editorial review is a legitimate marketing asset only when it is labeled as what it is.
Frequently asked questions
What is a paid editorial book review?
A paid editorial review is a professional critique written by a reviewer at a recognized review service, which the author pays to commission. It appears in the Editorial Reviews section of a book page and in trade channels, unlike a customer review written by an ordinary reader.
Is paying for a book review legitimate?
Yes, when the review is an honest editorial review from a real reviewer and is presented as such. It is not legitimate to buy fake customer reviews, incentivized reader reviews, or review swaps, which retailers prohibit and remove.
How much does a professional book review cost?
Prices range from free at Readers Favorite to $450 for Kirkus Indie's most popular option, with most established services between $149 and $600. Turnaround ranges from about four weeks to nine weeks depending on the service and speed chosen.
Can I keep a negative paid review private?
Most services in this list let you decide whether to publish the review, so a negative review can stay private. Readers Favorite and Kirkus both follow this model, which is a key reason authors trust paid editorial services.
Do book reviews help sell books?
A strong review from a recognized name helps with librarians, booksellers, media and some readers, and it gives you quotable lines for marketing. Reviews alone rarely drive large sales, so pair them with a good cover, accurate metadata and genuine reader outreach.
Sources we checked (11)
- https://www.kirkusreviews.com
- https://www.booklife.com
- https://www.forewordreviews.com
- https://www.blueinkreview.com
- https://www.indiereader.com
- https://reedsy.com/discovery
- https://www.selfpublishingreview.com
- https://readersfavorite.com
- https://www.kirkusreviews.com/indie-reviews/
- https://reedsy.com/discovery/blog/book-review-sites/
- https://atmospherepress.com/paid-editorial-reviews/
Is your product missing or out of date?
We review this list regularly. Vendors can request a listing, send updated pricing or ask about featured placement.
Shihab Mia · Founder, Rankite
Shihab has 5+ years in B2B and SaaS SEO. He writes Rankite's software buying guides from pricing pages, documentation and public user reviews. More about Shihab.
Kirkus Indie
BookLife
Foreword Clarion Reviews
BlueInk Review
IndieReader
Reedsy Discovery
Self-Publishing Review
Readers Favorite