How we make this list: we compare pricing pages, product documentation and public user reviews. Ratings come from G2, Capterra or Trustpilot, with the date we checked them.
What Is the Best Fish Delivery Service?
The best fish delivery service for most households is Wild Alaskan Company, because its boxes hold only wild-caught fish, portions are a full 6 ounces, shipping is free, and the 12-portion box costs 155 dollars per month. Fulton Fish Market is the best alternative when you want the widest choice, since it sells hundreds of items alongside curated boxes.
Key takeaways
- Wild Alaskan Company is the best overall pick for wild-caught subscription boxes, at 155 dollars per month for 12 portions with free shipping.
- Fulton Fish Market offers the widest selection, with a Starter Box at 142.99 dollars for 10 to 12 servings.
- Per-portion cost varies widely, from about 9.50 dollars at Sizzlefish to about 12.92 dollars at Wild Alaskan Company, so compare cost per portion, not box price.
- All eight services ship only within the United States, so plan freezer space before your first box arrives.
- Lobster specialists Maine Lobster Now and Lobster Anywhere suit live lobster and special occasions rather than everyday fish.
How Much Does Fish Delivery Cost per Box?
A monthly fish delivery box usually costs between 99 and 279 dollars. Small boxes with 10 to 14 portions run about 129 to 155 dollars per month, while larger 24-portion boxes run about 240 to 279 dollars. The box price alone does not tell you the real cost, so always divide by the number of portions. A 132.95 dollar Sizzlefish Prime Box with 14 portions works out to about 9.50 dollars per portion, while a 155 dollar Wild Alaskan Company box with 12 portions works out to about 12.92 dollars per portion. Shipping matters too, since Fulton Fish Market and Maine Lobster Now give free shipping on orders over 150 dollars.
How Fresh Is Delivered Fish and How Does Shipping Work?
Nearly all fish delivery services ship frozen, not fresh, and that is a good thing. Fish is flash frozen within hours of being caught, which locks in flavor and texture far better than fish that spends days on ice in a truck. Boxes travel in insulated packaging with dry ice or gel packs, and most arrive in one to three days. Wild Alaskan Company and Sizzlefish ship with free ground shipping on subscription boxes, while Maine Lobster Now and Lobster Anywhere use FedEx overnight for live lobsters. When the box arrives, check that the fish is still frozen solid, move it to the freezer right away, and thaw only what you plan to cook that day.
Wild-Caught vs Farmed: Which Should You Buy?
Wild-caught fish comes from oceans and rivers, while farmed fish is raised in pens or ponds. Wild-caught salmon, cod, and halibut tend to be leaner, with a firmer texture and a stronger flavor, and they avoid the antibiotics and crowded conditions that some fish farms use. In this guide, Wild Alaskan Company, Vital Choice, Sitka Seafood Market, and Sizzlefish focus on wild-caught fish, while Fulton Fish Market and Crowd Cow sell a mix of wild and farmed species. If wild sourcing matters to you, look for Marine Stewardship Council certification, and note that Sitka Seafood Market tells members which boat caught their fish.
How to Choose the Right Fish Delivery Service
Start with how often you eat fish and how many people you feed. A single person who eats fish twice a week needs about 8 to 12 portions a month, while a family of four needs 24 portions or more. Next, decide whether you want a subscription or one-time orders. Subscriptions from Wild Alaskan Company, Vital Choice, Sitka Seafood Market, and Sizzlefish save money and keep the freezer stocked, but they only make sense if you cook fish regularly. Finally, check the cancellation policy: the best services let you pause, skip, or cancel from your online account without a phone call.
Worked Example: What One Month of Fish Delivery Really Costs
Suppose you want one box of about 12 portions for two people eating fish twice a week. With Wild Alaskan Company, the 12-portion box costs 155 dollars and shipping is free, so the month costs 155 dollars, or about 12.92 dollars per portion. With Sizzlefish, the 14-portion Prime Box costs 132.95 dollars with free shipping on orders over 100 dollars, so the month costs 132.95 dollars, or about 9.50 dollars per portion. With Vital Choice, the 129 dollar Wild Salmon Box can add 8 to 35 dollars in shipping, so the real monthly total can reach 137 to 164 dollars. The cheapest box price is not always the cheapest month.
Quick comparison
| Tool | Best for | Starting price | Free plan |
|---|
 Fulton Fish Market | Shoppers who want the widest choice of seafood in one place | $142.99 per Seafood Starter Box (vendor pricing page, checked 15 Nov 2026) | No free plan; first orders can use site promotions |
 Vital Choice | Wild-caught salmon lovers who want a monthly subscription | $129 per month for the Wild Salmon Box (third-party reported; vendor page did not list box prices on 15 Nov 2026) | No free plan; loyalty points earned on purchases |
 Sitka Seafood Market | Buyers who want to know exactly which boat caught their fish | From $99 per box (third-party reported; vendor pricing page did not list a price on 15 Nov 2026, and other sources report $154.44 to $159 per box) | No free plan; first box promotions such as $25 off are offered |
 Wild Alaskan Company | Households that want a simple wild-caught subscription with free shipping | $155 per month for a 12-portion box (third-party reported Nov 2026; an older vendor price was $145, so confirm at checkout) | No free plan; $25 off the first box is commonly offered |
 Sizzlefish | Budget-conscious buyers who want the lowest cost per portion | $132.95 per shipment for the 14-portion Prime Box (third-party reported; vendor pricing page did not list a price on 15 Nov 2026) | No free plan; free shipping on orders over $100 |
 Maine Lobster Now | Live Maine lobster shipped overnight to your door | From $42.49 for fresh lobster meat (vendor pricing page, checked 15 Nov 2026); live lobsters from $19.31 each (third-party reported) | No free plan; free overnight shipping on orders over $150 |
 Lobster Anywhere | Lobster gifts, dinner packages, and special occasion orders | From $46 per 1.25 lb live lobster (third-party reported); lobster tail special from $149.95 for four tails (vendor site, Nov 2026) | No free plan; free express delivery on many gift packages |
 Crowd Cow | Shoppers who want to mix seafood with meat in one custom box | $149 minimum first box (vendor site, checked 15 Nov 2026); $99 minimum on later subscription boxes | No free plan; membership gives 5 percent off and free shipping from $125 |
Is your product missing or out of date?
We review this list regularly. Vendors can request a listing, send updated pricing or ask about featured placement.
8 Best Fish Delivery Services in 2026
| Tool | Best for | Starting price | Free plan |
| Fulton Fish Market | Widest selection and one-time orders | $142.99 per Starter Box | No free plan |
| Vital Choice | Wild-caught salmon subscriptions | $129 per month | No free plan |
| Sitka Seafood Market | Small-boat traceability | From $99 per box | No free plan |
| Wild Alaskan Company | Best overall wild-caught subscription | $155 per month | No free plan |
| Sizzlefish | Lowest cost per portion | $132.95 per shipment | No free plan |
| Maine Lobster Now | Live Maine lobster delivery | From $42.49 | No free plan |
| Lobster Anywhere | Lobster gifts and dinner packages | From $46 per 1.25 lb lobster | No free plan |
| Crowd Cow | Build-your-own seafood and meat boxes | $149 minimum first box | No free plan |
Starting price$142.99 per Seafood Starter Box (vendor pricing page, checked 15 Nov 2026)
Free planNo free plan; first orders can use site promotions
Fulton Fish Market is the online arm of the historic New York fish market, and it shows in the range on offer. The Seafood Starter Box costs 142.99 dollars for 10 to 12 servings and includes salmon portions, wild cod, colossal shrimp, and crab cakes, which makes it a strong first order. Shipping is free on subscription orders over 150 dollars and one-time orders over 200 dollars. The main drawback is price: Fulton is not the cheapest per portion, and small orders carry a real extra cost.
What we like- Largest selection here, with hundreds of fish, shellfish, and prepared items
- Curated boxes and a la carte ordering
- Free shipping on subscription orders over 150 dollars
Watch out for- Free shipping threshold is higher than most rivals, and smaller orders pay a 19.99 dollar flat shipping fee
Starting price$129 per month for the Wild Salmon Box (third-party reported; vendor page did not list box prices on 15 Nov 2026)
Free planNo free plan; loyalty points earned on purchases
Vital Choice has sold wild-caught seafood since 2001 and built its name on sustainability. Its Vital Box subscription comes in three tiers: the Wild Salmon Box at 129 dollars per month for 10 to 14 servings, the Wild Fish Box at 169 dollars for 14 to 16 servings, and the Wild Seafood Box at 199 dollars for 18 to 22 servings. The catalog also covers halibut, cod, sablefish, scallops, and smoked salmon, with many items carrying Marine Stewardship Council certification. The weak point is shipping, since frozen seafood needs express delivery and third-party reviews report per-item fees that add up fast.
What we like- Strictly wild-caught, sustainably sourced seafood
- Three Vital Box tiers from salmon-only to full seafood
- Large catalog of single items
Watch out for- Shipping fees are charged per item on some orders and can reach 10 to 25 dollars per item for express frozen delivery
Starting priceFrom $99 per box (third-party reported; vendor pricing page did not list a price on 15 Nov 2026, and other sources report $154.44 to $159 per box)
Free planNo free plan; first box promotions such as $25 off are offered
Sitka Seafood Market began in 2012 as Sitka Salmon Shares, a community-supported fishery model that pays small-boat fishermen fairly. Members choose a Premium Salmon subscription or a Reserve subscription, each delivering at least 4.5 pounds of wild-caught seafood per box, with two varieties in most deliveries. The company buys top-tier fish from a hook-and-line cooperative and tells members which boat caught their fish. Subscriptions can be paused, skipped, or cancelled at any time. Pricing is the main problem: sources conflict between 99 and 159 dollars per box, so confirm the current price before ordering.
What we like- Small-boat sourcing with boat-level traceability
- 100 percent money-back guarantee
- Flexible delivery with easy skipping
Watch out for- Prices are higher than most rivals per pound, and published prices conflict, so the real cost is hard to pin down before checkout
Starting price$155 per month for a 12-portion box (third-party reported Nov 2026; an older vendor price was $145, so confirm at checkout)
Free planNo free plan; $25 off the first box is commonly offered
Wild Alaskan Company is the best overall pick in this guide because it keeps the model simple and the quality high. Three boxes are on offer: the Wild Salmon Box, the Wild White Fish Box, and the Wild Combo Box, each available in 12 portions for 155 dollars per month or 24 portions for 279 dollars per month, with free ground shipping included. Portions are 5 to 7 ounces, and delivery can be monthly, every six weeks, or every two months. The main limits are that the core boxes require a subscription, with no one-time purchase option, and the service does not ship to Hawaii or internationally. Price caveat: third-party reviews report 155 dollars, while an older vendor announcement listed 145 dollars.
What we like- Only wild-caught fish from Alaska and the Pacific Northwest
- Free ground shipping on every box
- Generous 5 to 7 ounce portions
Watch out for- No one-time ordering for the core boxes, since the service is subscription only
#5
Sizzlefish
Best for: Budget-conscious buyers who want the lowest cost per portion
Visit sizzlefish.com
Starting price$132.95 per shipment for the 14-portion Prime Box (third-party reported; vendor pricing page did not list a price on 15 Nov 2026)
Free planNo free plan; free shipping on orders over $100
Sizzlefish sells subscription boxes of sustainably caught fish and shellfish in pre-portioned 4 to 6 ounce servings. The Prime Box costs 132.95 dollars per shipment for 14 portions, the Wild Seafood Favorites box costs 129.95 dollars for 10 to 14 portions, and the Prime Plus box costs 145.95 dollars for 14 portions, with 28-portion versions for larger households. Shipping is free on orders over 100 dollars, with delivery in one to three days. Recent third-party reviews from November 2026 report spoiled products and a build-your-own menu that shrinks to about 12 items at checkout. Start with one box and inspect it on arrival.
What we like- Lowest cost per portion in this guide at about 9.50 dollars
- Free shipping on orders over 100 dollars
- Pre-cut 4 to 6 ounce portions
Watch out for- Recent third-party reviews report a sharp drop in quality and limited build-your-own selection, with only about 12 items available
Starting priceFrom $42.49 for fresh lobster meat (vendor pricing page, checked 15 Nov 2026); live lobsters from $19.31 each (third-party reported)
Free planNo free plan; free overnight shipping on orders over $150
Maine Lobster Now buys lobsters directly from two partner docks in Maine and ships them live across the United States. Live lobsters start at 19.31 dollars each according to third-party pricing, with a 2 pound lobster listed at 62.99 dollars and a 3 pound lobster at 89.99 dollars on the vendor site, while fresh lobster meat starts at 42.49 dollars. Orders placed by 8 AM Eastern, Monday through Friday, ship for next-day delivery Tuesday through Saturday. Orders over 150 dollars ship overnight for free. The tight 4-hour window to report delivery problems is the main drawback, so inspect the box as soon as it arrives.
What we like- Live lobsters sourced directly from Maine fishermen with dock traceability
- Free overnight shipping over 150 dollars
- Wide range of tails and meat
Watch out for- Shipping is a flat 40 dollars on orders under 150 dollars, and you have only 4 hours after delivery to report a problem
Starting priceFrom $46 per 1.25 lb live lobster (third-party reported); lobster tail special from $149.95 for four tails (vendor site, Nov 2026)
Free planNo free plan; free express delivery on many gift packages
Lobster Anywhere has shipped lobster across the United States for more than 25 years, and its range suits gifts and celebrations better than everyday fish. Live Maine lobsters run from 46 dollars for a 1.25 pound lobster to 179 dollars for a 5 to 6 pound lobster, while the popular lobster tails Christmas special starts at 149.95 dollars for four 6 to 7 ounce tails with free express delivery. Prepared options include lobster bisque, chowder, lobster roll kits, and surf and turf dinners. Deliveries run Tuesday through Saturday. Small orders face steep shipping, so for the best value, order a gift package with free express delivery included.
What we like- Shipping lobster to all 50 states since 1999
- Large gift and dinner selection, including surf and turf and lobster roll kits
Watch out for- Shipping fees depend on the order total and can reach 29 to 49 dollars on small orders, plus a 19 dollar Saturday surcharge
#8
Crowd Cow
Best for: Shoppers who want to mix seafood with meat in one custom box
Visit crowdcow.com
Starting price$149 minimum first box (vendor site, checked 15 Nov 2026); $99 minimum on later subscription boxes
Free planNo free plan; membership gives 5 percent off and free shipping from $125
Crowd Cow connects buyers directly with more than 50 independent farms and fisheries, and its seafood range covers salmon, shrimp, scallops, lobster tails, and premium sushi items such as bluefin tuna and Hokkaido uni. You can shop a la carte or subscribe and skip, swap, or cancel at any time. The first box has a 149 dollar minimum, which drops to 99 dollars on later subscription boxes, and shipping is 19.99 dollars flat to the lower 48 states, free at 149 dollars or more. The trade-off is focus, since Crowd Cow is mainly a meat company and does not ship to Alaska, Hawaii, or Puerto Rico.
What we like- Full customization with about 50 seafood items from named farms and fisheries
- No subscription required
- Farm-level traceability
Watch out for- Fish selection is narrower than the specialist services, and the 149 dollar first-box minimum is high for a trial order
Frequently asked questions
How much should I expect to pay for fish delivery each month?
Most households spend 129 to 279 dollars per month on a fish delivery subscription. A 12 to 14 portion box costs about 129 to 155 dollars, which covers two fish meals a week for two people. Larger 24-portion boxes cost 240 to 279 dollars and suit families of four. Always add shipping to the box price, then divide by portions.
Is delivered fish as fresh as fish from a local market?
Delivered fish is usually flash frozen within hours of being caught, which preserves flavor and texture better than fish that sits on ice for days. Most services ship in insulated boxes with dry ice, and the fish arrives frozen solid. Thaw it in the fridge overnight and cook it the same day.
Do these fish delivery services ship outside the United States?
No, all eight services in this guide ship only within the United States, and most cover only the contiguous 48 states. Wild Alaskan Company and Crowd Cow do not ship to Hawaii, and several services add surcharges for Alaska, Hawaii, and some rural states. If you live outside the United States, look for a local seafood delivery service instead.
Can I pause or cancel a fish delivery subscription?
Yes, all the subscription services in this guide let you pause, skip, or cancel from your online account. Wild Alaskan Company, Vital Choice, Sitka Seafood Market, and Sizzlefish all offer monthly, six-week, or two-month delivery intervals. Cancel before the next billing date to avoid being charged.
Which fish delivery service is best for a first order?
Fulton Fish Market is the best first order for most buyers, because the 142.99 dollar Seafood Starter Box includes salmon, cod, shrimp, and crab cakes in one shipment with no subscription required. If you want a subscription instead, start with the 12-portion Wild Alaskan Company box at 155 dollars with free shipping. Order one box first and check the quality before committing to regular deliveries.
Sources we checked (15)
- https://fultonfishmarket.com/products/fulton-seafood-starter-box
- https://www.vitalchoice.com/v/seafood-subscriptions
- https://www.breakfastcriminals.com/vital-choice-review/
- https://sitkaseafoodmarket.com/pages/choose-your-plan
- https://support.sitkaseafoodmarket.com/hc/en-us/articles/38197275403284-What-purchase-options-does-Sitka-Seafood-Market-offer
- https://wildalaskancompany.com/pricing
- http://mmanuts.com/reviews/wild-alaskan-company-reviews/
- https://hellosubscription.com/shop/sizzlefish/
- https://www.topconsumerreviews.com/best-seafood-stores/reviews/sizzlefish.php
- https://www.mainelobsternow.com/
- https://www.mainelobsternow.com/products/2-lb-live-maine-lobster
- https://lobsteranywhere.com/holidays-celebrations/lobster-christmas-gift-guide/
- https://lobsteranywhere.com/shop/lobster-meat/
- https://www.crowdcow.sbs/best-meat-subscription-box
- https://www.crowdcow.com/products/essential-sashimi-kit?offer=iurmrhlhbvd
Is your product missing or out of date?
We review this list regularly. Vendors can request a listing, send updated pricing or ask about featured placement.
Shihab Mia · Founder, Rankite
Shihab has 5+ years in B2B and SaaS SEO. He writes Rankite's software buying guides from pricing pages, documentation and public user reviews. More about Shihab.