How we make this list: we compare pricing pages, product documentation and public user reviews. Ratings come from G2, Capterra or Trustpilot, with the date we checked them.
Key takeaways
- Judge.me is the cheapest way to collect unlimited product reviews on Shopify, at a flat $15 per month for the paid plan.
- Loox and Okendo suit visual and data-rich brands, but their order-based pricing rises as a store grows.
- Stamped and Growave replace both reviews and loyalty in one app, which can cut the number of vendors a store manages.
- Reviews.io and Trustpilot focus on company reputation and Google visibility, rather than on-product reviews alone.
Quick comparison
| Tool | Best for | Starting price | Free plan |
|---|
 Judge.me | Unlimited reviews at a flat price | $15 per month (Awesome) | Yes |
 Stamped | Reviews plus loyalty from one vendor | $23 per month (200 orders) | No |
 Loox | Photo and video reviews | $49.99 per month (Convert, 300 orders) | Yes |
 Okendo | Reviews with customer data and surveys | $19 per month (Essential, 200 orders) | Yes |
 Reviews.io | Company reviews and Google visibility | $29 per month (Essentials) | No |
 Trustpilot | Trusted third-party company reviews | See website | Yes |
 Smile.io | Points and VIP loyalty programs | $15 per month (Essential) | Yes |
 Growave | Reviews, loyalty and wishlists together | $15 per month (Entry, 500 orders) | Yes |
 Fera | Reviews plus social proof on a budget | $9 per month (Startup) | No |
Is your product missing or out of date?
We review this list regularly. Vendors can request a listing, send updated pricing or ask about featured placement.
The best Yotpo alternatives
Starting price$15 per month (Awesome)
Free planYes
Judge.me is the first tool most Shopify owners should test when leaving Yotpo over price. The free plan already collects unlimited reviews with photos and video, and the Awesome plan at $15 per month adds AI summaries, review replies and deeper customization, all at a flat rate. A store doing 500 orders a month pays the same as a store doing 5,000, which is rare in this category.
The main limit is platform. Judge.me now focuses on Shopify, so a store on WooCommerce or BigCommerce needs another tool. Loyalty also comes through integrations with apps such as Smile.io, rather than inside Judge.me itself. For a Shopify store that mainly needs product reviews done well and cheaply, Judge.me is hard to beat.
What we like- Unlimited reviews on the free and paid plans
- Flat price does not rise with orders
- Google and social syndication
Watch out for- Shopify only, which limits other platforms
- Design customization needs care on the free plan
- Loyalty needs a separate app
#2Stamped
Best for: Reviews plus loyalty from one vendor4.6/5 on
G2 (27 reviews, checked Oct 2026)
Visit stamped.io
Starting price$23 per month (200 orders)
Free planNo
Stamped suits a store that wants to cut vendors rather than just cut the review bill. Reviews, loyalty, referrals and NPS surveys can run from one dashboard, and the Klaviyo integration lets review and loyalty events feed email flows. That single system also means one support team and one set of customer data to manage.
Pricing starts at $23 per month for 200 orders, with no free plan to test the full feature set first. Loyalty sits as a separate product at higher levels, so the total cost for reviews plus loyalty is higher than the entry price suggests. Stamped fits an established brand that values one vendor and a clean Klaviyo link over the lowest possible price.
What we like- Reviews, loyalty and referrals in one system
- Strong Klaviyo integration
- NPS surveys included
Watch out for- No free plan
- Loyalty is a separate product at higher tiers
- Order-based pricing rises with growth
#3Loox
Best for: Photo and video reviews4.9/5 on
G2 (30 reviews, checked Oct 2026)
Visit loox.io
Starting price$49.99 per month (Convert, 300 orders)
Free planYes
Loox is built for brands where the photo sells the product, such as beauty, fashion, home goods and food. Customers upload photos and videos with their reviews, and Loox turns them into galleries, carousels and social proof widgets that look good on a product page. Referral features add a second growth channel without another app.
The price is the hurdle. The free plan covers up to 500 orders with basic features, but the Convert plan at $49.99 per month for 300 orders is a jump for a small store. Order-based pricing also rises as sales grow, so model the cost at your peak month, not your average. For a visual brand with strong customer photos, Loox can justify the price in conversion alone.
What we like- Photo and video reviews that convert well
- Attractive galleries and widgets
- Referral features included
Watch out for- Paid plan starts high for small stores
- Order-based pricing rises steeply
- Shopify only
#4Okendo
Best for: Reviews with customer data and surveys4.7/5 on
G2 (494 reviews, checked Oct 2026)
Visit okendo.io
Starting price$19 per month (Essential, 200 orders)
Free planYes
Okendo goes beyond star ratings by collecting attributes, such as fit, quality and use case, plus survey answers that build a customer profile. A brand can then segment shoppers by what they bought, how they rated it and what they said about it, and use that data in email and loyalty flows. That depth suits data-driven direct brands that already segment their marketing.
The free plan covers up to 50 orders per month, and Essential starts at $19 per month for 200 orders, so costs rise with order volume. Deeper integrations sit on the Power plan, which is far pricier. Okendo fits a growing Shopify brand that will actually use review data for segmentation, not a store that only needs stars on a product page.
What we like- Rich review attributes and surveys
- Customer profiles for segmentation
- Loyalty as a separate product
Watch out for- Order-based pricing rises with volume
- Advanced email and SMS links sit on higher plans
- Shopify only
#5Reviews.io
Best for: Company reviews and Google visibility4.8/5 on
G2 (657 reviews, checked Oct 2026)
Visit reviews.io
Starting price$29 per month (Essentials)
Free planNo
Reviews.io solves a different problem from Judge.me or Loox. It collects company reviews that feed Google Seller Ratings and search visibility, which helps a brand look credible before a shopper ever reaches a product page. Video reviews and invitation tools support that reputation goal, and the platform works on Shopify, WooCommerce and custom sites alike.
Stores that mainly need on-product reviews may find the product widgets less rich than a Shopify-native app. Pricing is per domain, so a multi-store brand pays more, and there is no free plan. Reviews.io fits a brand whose weak spot is search trust and company reputation, rather than a single product page.
What we like- Company reviews that support Google Seller Ratings
- Video reviews
- Works on any platform, not only Shopify
Watch out for- Product review widgets are less central than company reviews
- Pricing is per domain
- No free plan
#6Trustpilot
Best for: Trusted third-party company reviews3.3/5 on
G2 (265 reviews, checked Oct 2026)
Visit trustpilot.com
Starting priceSee website
Free planYes
Trustpilot is the best-known independent review platform for many shoppers, and that recognition is its main asset. A Trustpilot profile with recent, genuine reviews can reassure a first-time buyer in a way that reviews hosted only on your own site cannot. Invitation tools, widgets and search visibility support that trust across the web.
The cost is the catch. Paid plans are priced for larger brands, and the free plan is limited, so a small store may get less value than from a product review app. Trustpilot also focuses on company reviews, not detailed product attributes. It fits a brand that sells on trust across many channels and wants an independent voice behind its reputation.
What we like- High consumer recognition as an independent review site
- Strong SEO and search presence
- Invitation and widget tools
Watch out for- Paid plans are costly for small stores
- Product reviews are not the focus
- Negative reviews are public and cannot be removed
#7Smile.io
Best for: Points and VIP loyalty programs4.6/5 on
G2 (469 reviews, checked Oct 2026)
Visit smile.io
Starting price$15 per month (Essential)
Free planYes
Smile.io is the loyalty half of a Yotpo replacement, and it pairs naturally with Judge.me for reviews. Points for purchases, referrals and account creation are quick to set up, and the free plan covers up to 200 orders per month. Paid plans add integrations, a loyalty landing page and removal of Smile branding.
VIP tiers, which many growing brands want, sit on the Growth plan at $199 per month, and the Plus plan jumps further, so the price curve at volume is steep. Smile.io fits a Shopify store that wants a simple, proven loyalty program now, with a clear plan to review costs before each tier jump.
What we like- Fast setup for points and referrals
- Free plan up to 200 orders
- Klaviyo and email integrations on paid plans
Watch out for- VIP tiers sit on higher plans
- Price jumps sharply at volume
- Review rewards need a review app link
Starting price$15 per month (Entry, 500 orders)
Free planYes
Growave bundles the retention tools that many stores buy separately, which are reviews, loyalty points, wishlists and referrals, into one Shopify app. That bundle keeps the storefront consistent and reduces the number of apps to maintain. The free plan covers up to 200 orders, and Entry starts at $15 per month for 500 orders.
Specialist apps still go deeper in their own areas. Loox beats Growave on visual reviews, and Smile.io beats it on loyalty depth at the top end. Growave fits a small to mid-size Shopify store that wants one retention app at a fair price, rather than the best tool for each single job.
What we like- Reviews, loyalty, wishlists and referrals in one app
- Free plan up to 200 orders
- Lower entry price than many suites
Watch out for- Shopify only
- Some features are simpler than specialist apps
- Higher plans rise with order volume
#9
Fera
Best for: Reviews plus social proof on a budget
Visit fera.ai
Starting price$9 per month (Startup)
Free planNo
Fera is the budget pick for a store that wants reviews and social proof without a large monthly bill. The Startup plan starts at $9 per month, and the app adds popups and notifications that show recent purchases and reviews to new visitors. A long trial gives time to test widgets and request flows before committing.
Entry limits matter. Review requests and orders are capped on lower plans, so a busy store will need a higher tier. The feature set is also narrower than Judge.me or Okendo for deep customization. Fera fits a new or small store that needs credible reviews and social proof at the lowest workable price.
What we like- Low starting price
- Social proof notifications alongside reviews
- Long free trial for testing
Watch out for- No free plan
- Smaller feature set than larger rivals
- Review request limits on the entry plan
How we chose
We compared vendor pricing pages and Shopify App Store listings, then checked public reviews on G2, Capterra and Shopify, plus merchant discussion on Reddit, for recurring complaints about order limits, migration and support. We kept only tools that exist today, serve ecommerce stores in the US, and replace at least one core part of Yotpo, which is reviews, loyalty or company reputation. We did not claim hands-on testing, and we treated every price as a starting point to confirm at your order volume.
Modeling the real cost at your volume
Do not compare entry prices alone. Write down your monthly orders, your review request volume and whether you need loyalty, SMS or Google syndication, then price each tool at that volume. A flat-price app like Judge.me can be far cheaper than an order-based app at 2,000 orders a month, while an order-based app can be cheaper at 100 orders a month on a free plan.
Migration and review import
Ask how your existing Yotpo reviews import, including photos, ratings and review dates, and whether Google rich snippets will keep working during the switch. Test widgets on mobile, since most shoppers read reviews on a phone, and check that review request emails land in the inbox rather than spam. A clean import protects years of trust that a new app cannot rebuild quickly.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest Yotpo alternative?
Judge.me is the cheapest strong alternative for Shopify stores, with a free plan for unlimited reviews and a flat $15 per month paid plan. Fera starts lower at $9 per month, but its entry plan caps review requests, so Judge.me usually costs less at real volume.
Can I replace Yotpo loyalty and reviews with one app?
Yes, Stamped and Growave both offer reviews plus loyalty in one system, while Okendo offers reviews with loyalty as a separate product. A single app simplifies billing and data, but check whether loyalty features sit on a higher tier before you compare prices.
Do these alternatives work with Klaviyo?
Judge.me, Stamped, Okendo and Smile.io all integrate with Klaviyo, though the depth varies by plan. Confirm that review, loyalty and referral events sync on the plan you will buy, since some links need a higher tier or a separate integration step.
Will my reviews still show on Google?
Many of these tools support Google Seller Ratings and rich snippets, including Judge.me, Reviews.io and Trustpilot, but eligibility depends on review volume, recency and Google rules. Keep collecting reviews during migration, and check that snippets still appear after the switch.
Is it hard to migrate from Yotpo?
Migration is usually a matter of exporting reviews and importing them into the new app, then restyling widgets and reconnecting email flows. The main risks are lost photos, broken snippets and a gap in review requests, so run the new app alongside Yotpo for a short overlap if possible.
Which alternative is best for a visual brand?
Loox is the best fit for a visual brand, because photo and video reviews are its core strength and its galleries are built to convert. Judge.me also collects photo and video reviews at a lower price, but its widgets are less focused on visual storytelling than Loox.
Sources we checked (9)
- https://www.judge.me
- https://www.stamped.io
- https://www.loox.io
- https://www.okendo.io
- https://www.reviews.io
- https://www.trustpilot.com
- https://www.smile.io
- https://www.growave.io
- https://www.fera.ai
Is your product missing or out of date?
We review this list regularly. Vendors can request a listing, send updated pricing or ask about featured placement.
Shihab Mia · Founder, Rankite
Shihab has 5+ years in B2B and SaaS SEO. He writes Rankite's software buying guides from pricing pages, documentation and public user reviews. More about Shihab.