How we make this list: we compare pricing pages, product documentation and public user reviews. Ratings come from G2, Capterra or Trustpilot, with the date we checked them.
Key takeaways
- This article interprets "best insurance companies to work" as the best insurance employers to work for, judged on employee survey rankings, culture, and career growth.
- Eight insurers made the 2026 Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work For list, compiled with Great Place To Work from surveys of over 1.3 million employees.
- Progressive leads the insurance group at No. 19, with MetLife at No. 31 and Allianz Life at No. 79, and Progressive has featured on the list for eight consecutive years.
- Insurance careers span claims, underwriting, data, technology, sales, and customer service, so the best employer depends on the role you want, not only the brand.
- Rankings reflect employee trust, values, and leadership, not pay for a specific role. Always check the actual job posting, team, and location before applying.
Quick comparison
| Tool | Best for | Starting price | Free plan |
|---|
 Progressive | Digital scale and internal mobility | See website | Not applicable |
 MetLife | Global benefits and stability | See website | Not applicable |
 Ally Financial | Digital-first culture | See website | Not applicable |
 Elevance Health | Health insurance careers | See website | Not applicable |
 First American Financial | Title and real estate services | See website | Not applicable |
 SCAN Health Plan | Mission-driven health plans | See website | Not applicable |
 Crum and Forster | Specialty commercial insurance | See website | Not applicable |
 Allianz Life | Retirement and life insurance | See website | Not applicable |
Is your product missing or out of date?
We review this list regularly. Vendors can request a listing, send updated pricing or ask about featured placement.
The best insurance companies to work for
Starting priceSee website
Free planNot applicable
Progressive tops the insurance contingent on the 2026 Fortune list at No. 19, after placing No. 54 in 2023, No. 35 in 2024, and No. 16 in 2025. The company says it has now featured on the list for eight consecutive years, and Fortune reported revenue near $75 billion in 2024 after nearly doubling over five years.
The career story is internal mobility: roughly 40 percent of the workforce moves into new roles each year, which suits people who want to change functions without changing employers. Claims and customer roles can be high volume, and pace is fast at this scale. For an insurance career with room to move, Progressive is the strongest overall pick here.
What we like- No. 19 on the 2026 Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work For list
- Eight consecutive years on the list
- Roughly 40 percent of the workforce moves into new roles each year
Watch out for- Large-company pace and change
- Claims and customer roles can be high volume
- Office expectations vary by role
Starting priceSee website
Free planNot applicable
MetLife follows Progressive on the 2026 Fortune list at No. 31, reflecting employee trust, values, and leadership scores from the Great Place To Work survey. Its scale spans life insurance, employee benefits, and retirement products across many countries, which gives employees global career paths that smaller insurers cannot match.
Large-company bureaucracy is the trade-off, and experience varies widely by team and country, so the specific role matters more than the brand. For a stable, global insurance employer with benefits depth, MetLife is a strong choice, especially for benefits and group insurance careers.
What we like- No. 31 on the 2026 Fortune list
- Global scale across life, benefits, and retirement
- Long history and financial strength
Watch out for- Large-company bureaucracy
- Role experience varies widely by team and country
- Change programs are frequent
Starting priceSee website
Free planNot applicable
Ally Financial sits at No. 51 on the 2026 Fortune list, and its appeal is digital-first culture. Built around online banking and auto finance, Ally operates without the branch network of traditional banks, which shapes a technology-led workplace that suits engineers, data analysts, and digital product staff.
Its insurance footprint is smaller than pure insurers, and roles skew toward banking and auto finance rather than traditional underwriting or agency work. For a candidate who wants insurance-adjacent work in a digital company, Ally is an attractive employer. For a classic insurance career, the pure insurers below fit better.
What we like- No. 51 on the 2026 Fortune list
- Digital-first banking and insurance culture
- Modern technology stack for a financial firm
Watch out for- Smaller insurance footprint than pure insurers
- Roles skew toward banking and auto finance
- Fewer traditional agency paths
Starting priceSee website
Free planNot applicable
Elevance Health, formerly Anthem, ranks No. 61 on the 2026 Fortune list and is the health insurance employer on this list. Its scale covers health plans, care delivery, pharmacy, and data, which opens roles beyond traditional insurance, including clinical operations, health data, and care management.
Health industry regulation adds complexity, and large-company structure means team experience varies. For a career in health insurance specifically, Elevance Health is the leading large employer here, with paths into care and data that pure property insurers do not offer.
What we like- No. 61 on the 2026 Fortune list
- Large health insurance scale
- Care, pharmacy, and data roles alongside traditional insurance jobs
Watch out for- Health industry regulation and complexity
- Large-company structure
- Role experience varies by business unit
#5
First American Financial
Best for: Title and real estate services
Visit firstam.com
Starting priceSee website
Free planNot applicable
First American Financial ranks No. 62 on the 2026 Fortune list and leads in title insurance and real estate services. Its business follows housing transactions, which gives steady work in active markets and a specialist career path in title, escrow, and real estate data that general insurers do not offer.
Housing cycles affect volume, and title work is detail-heavy, which suits careful operators more than fast-moving sales staff. For a specialist career in real estate services with a ranked employer, First American Financial is the pick here.
What we like- No. 62 on the 2026 Fortune list
- Leader in title insurance and real estate services
- Steady demand tied to housing transactions
Watch out for- Housing market cycles affect volume
- Title work is detail-heavy
- Fewer technology roles than digital insurers
Starting priceSee website
Free planNot applicable
SCAN Health Plan ranks No. 70 on the 2026 Fortune list and stands out as a mission-driven health plan focused on older adults. Smaller scale than national carriers means employees often hold broader roles with more visibility, which suits people who want impact over corporate ladder climbing.
Regional concentration limits roles outside its core markets, and total headcount is far smaller than the national names here. For a mission-driven health plan career with a ranked culture, SCAN is a distinctive choice, especially for candidates drawn to senior care.
What we like- No. 70 on the 2026 Fortune list
- Mission-driven focus on older adults
- Smaller scale means broader roles and visibility
Watch out for- Smaller than national carriers
- Regional concentration
- Fewer roles outside its core markets
#7
Crum and Forster
Best for: Specialty commercial insurance
Visit cfins.com
Starting priceSee website
Free planNot applicable
Crum and Forster ranks No. 78 on the 2026 Fortune list and is the specialty commercial insurer here. Its lines cover commercial risks that personal-lines carriers do not touch, which suits underwriters, claims specialists, and brokers who want depth in a niche rather than volume in auto or home insurance.
Specialty focus narrows some paths, and brand recognition is lower than Progressive or MetLife. For a commercial insurance specialist career with a ranked employer, Crum and Forster offers depth and group stability through its parent, Fairfax Financial.
What we like- No. 78 on the 2026 Fortune list
- Specialty commercial lines depth
- Part of Fairfax Financial, giving group stability
Watch out for- Specialty focus narrows some career paths
- Smaller brand recognition than national personal-lines carriers
- Commercial cycles affect lines
Starting priceSee website
Free planNot applicable
Allianz Life ranks No. 79 on the 2026 Fortune list and is the retirement and life insurance employer here. As part of Allianz, one of the largest financial services groups in the world, it offers stability and a global parent, with a product focus on life insurance and fixed and variable annuities.
Annuity products are complex, and distribution through financial professionals shapes many roles toward advisor support and product work. For a life and retirement career inside a global group, Allianz Life is a strong employer pick, especially for candidates interested in retirement income products.
What we like- No. 79 on the 2026 Fortune list
- Part of Allianz, one of the largest financial services groups in the world
- Retirement and annuity focus
Watch out for- Product complexity in annuities
- Distribution through financial professionals shapes many roles
- Large-group processes
How we chose
We based this list on the 2026 Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work For list, compiled by Fortune and Great Place To Work from confidential surveys of over 1.3 million employees, scoring trust, innovation, company values, and leadership effectiveness. We included all eight insurers on that list and left out AI-visibility rankings, which measure how often assistants name a company, not how employees rate it. Rankings are a snapshot of employee sentiment, not a guarantee about any single role, team, or location.
How to pick an insurance company to work for
Start with the role, not the ranking. Claims, underwriting, data, technology, sales, and customer service are different jobs, and the best employer for one may be average for another. Check the actual team, manager, location, and work pattern in the posting, and talk to current employees about the role you want before deciding.
Read rankings as a starting point, not a verdict
Fortune rankings reflect broad employee sentiment across a whole company, while your experience depends on your team and manager. Use the list to shortlist employers, then verify with role-specific research: job descriptions, interview questions about turnover and promotion, and employee reviews for the function you would join.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best insurance company to work for?
Progressive leads the insurance group on the 2026 Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work For list at No. 19, with eight consecutive years on the list and strong internal mobility. MetLife at No. 31 and Allianz Life at No. 79 are also ranked, and the best choice depends on the role you want.
How does Fortune rank the best companies to work for?
Fortune and Great Place To Work survey employees confidentially, with over 1.3 million responses for the 2026 list, scoring trust, innovation, company values, and leadership effectiveness. Rankings reflect employee sentiment across the company, not pay for a specific role.
Do insurance companies hire remote workers?
Many do, depending on role. Technology, data, and some customer roles often allow remote or hybrid work, while claims field roles and agency roles are location-based. Check the work pattern in each posting, since it varies by team even within one company.
Is insurance a good career in 2026?
Yes for many people. The US insurance industry employs over 2.8 million people, and surveys report that more than half of insurance companies planned to increase headcount. Roles in data, technology, and specialty underwriting are in particular demand, though pay and growth vary by function.
Should I choose a large insurer or a specialist?
Large insurers offer mobility, training, and scale, while specialists offer depth and visibility. Progressive and MetLife suit candidates who want many internal paths. SCAN, Crum and Forster, and First American suit candidates who want a niche and broader roles.
What should I ask in an insurance job interview?
Ask about team turnover, promotion timelines, training for new hires, and how performance is measured in the role. Ask what a typical week looks like and how the team handled its last busy period. Answers to those questions predict your experience better than any ranking.
Sources we checked (8)
- https://www.progressive.com
- https://www.metlife.com
- https://www.ally.com
- https://www.elevancehealth.com
- https://www.firstam.com
- https://www.scanhealthplan.com
- https://www.cfins.com
- https://www.allianzlife.com
Is your product missing or out of date?
We review this list regularly. Vendors can request a listing, send updated pricing or ask about featured placement.
Shihab Mia · Founder, Rankite
Shihab has 5+ years in B2B and SaaS SEO. He writes Rankite's software buying guides from pricing pages, documentation and public user reviews. More about Shihab.